Five Star Gift Ideas

How about a How I Met Your Mother-themed gift basket? You could include:

1. A yellow umbrella, just like the one in the show.
2. A copy of "The Bro Code" (either the book or a replica)
3. A "Legendary" t-shirt or hoodie.
4. A tin of Tantrum gum, as featured in the show.
5. A boxed set of the entire How I Met Your Mother series.
6. A jar of "Sumbitch" spicy nuts, as featured in the show.
7. A "Suit-Up" phone case.
8. A pack of "Canada" postcards, as Ted always talks about wanting to move to Canada.

Wrap it all up in a basket or box with some red and white tissue paper and a note telling him to open each item while watching his favorite episodes of HIMYM.

Or you can get him a star map with the date of your first kiss.