Five Star Gift Ideas

How about getting her a collection of classic thriller movies or the latest suspense novels? You could also consider getting her a subscription to a streaming service for thriller movies or booking a "murder mystery" experience for the two of you to solve together. Additionally, you could surprise her with a visit to a popular haunted house or escape room attraction. Another thoughtful gift idea could be a personalized message on a custom-made hidden message necklace or bracelet.

Or you can get her a star map with the date of your first kiss.

Mandy Shepherd says about Under Lucky Stars star maps:

“I ordered my wife a star map for Valentine's day and it was lost in the mail , I emailed under the lucky star and they immediately took care of and I received it a few days later exactly the way I ordered it... totally recommend”